Permanent, indestructible and eternal: what Assagioli means when he says the Self does not change
Compiled by Kenneth Sørensen, MA, with help from Claude AI.
Assagioli returns again and again to one observation. Everything in the personality changes: sensations, feelings, desires, thoughts, roles, moods. Yet something in us remains the same through all of it. He calls this the permanence of the self. At the level of the Higher Self he speaks of it in stronger terms, as indestructible, immortal and eternal, and here he draws openly on the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita. Permanence is one of the essential qualities of the self, alongside its being contentless and its being a centre of pure awareness. This entry collects his statements on it, from the personal “I” to the transpersonal Self, and closes with the qualifications he himself made.
1. What permanence means: something that does not change with changing states
The starting point is an observation anyone can repeat. In The Mystery of the “I” Assagioli puts it this way:
“…while the phenomenal conscious ‘I’ identifies with the various contents of consciousness, there is something in us that does not identify itself, that does not change with changing states of mind, that always remains the same, fixed and unassailable. This is our true ‘I,’ the Center of our individuality, the very substance of our being.” — The Mystery of the “I”
In The Interplay of Psychic Forces he grounds the same point in the continuity of a whole life:
“…we can — indeed must — discover in ourselves a stable, fixed and permanent element. Its most direct and immediate subjective manifestation is the irrepressible sense of individual identity that persists in spite of and through all the vicissitudes and developments of psychic life, from childhood to old age, in spite of the most radical changes…” — The Interplay of Psychic Forces
He also argues for it from the way consciousness returns after sleep, fainting or anaesthesia:
“This leads us to assume that the re-appearance of the conscious self or ego is due to the existence of a permanent center, of a true Self situated beyond or ‘above’ it.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 18
2. The permanent factor: the personal self
Permanence is not reserved for the Higher Self. The personal “I”, the centre of self-awareness reached through disidentification, already has it. The self-identification exercise makes this explicit:
“It is the essence of myself—a center of pure self-consciousness and self-realization. It is the permanent factor in the ever varying flow of my personal life. It is that which gives me the sense of being, of permanence, of inner security.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 119
The version in The Act of Will (p. 215) keeps the phrase “the permanent factor in the ever varying flow of my personal life” and speaks of “a sense of being, of permanence, of inner balance.”
The practice that reveals it is observation. As the observer stands back from the contents of consciousness:
“This objective observation produces naturally, spontaneously and inevitably a sense of dis-identification from any and all of those psychological contents and activities. By contrast the stability, the permanency of the observer is realized.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 116
The Meditation Group for the New Age course gives the same contrast in its simplest form:
“The contents are manifold, changing, often conflicting, while the ‘I’ is self-identical, permanent, stable and, therefore, of a radically different nature from all those contents.” — Meditation Group for the New Age, Second Year, Set III, p. 3
and again, joining permanence to the attitude of the Observer:
“Dis-identification implies the assumption and maintenance of the inner attitude of the Observer; in other words, the achievements of true self-awareness, i.e., the awareness of That within us which, permanent and immutable, lies behind, or rather above, the endless variety of transient psychological states.” — Meditation Group for the New Age, Third Year, Set VI, p. 21
In a talk he answers those who say “there is no ego”:
“If you mean your whole personality, of course, most of which has to go. But if you mean the self, no, the point of self-awareness remains stable, immutable, permanent.” — Talks on the Self
Why should the personal self have this quality at all? Because it is a reflection of the Higher Self:
“…it reflects, however palely, the same qualities of its Source. If you look at the reflection of the sun on a mirror, or on water, you see the light and quality of the sun, infinitesimal, but still the quality of the sun. So that explains why even at the personality’s level the self is stable, sure, and indestructible.” — Talks on the Self
3. The Self as the permanent and eternal part of us
At the transpersonal level Assagioli’s language becomes stronger. In The Multiplicities Within the Human Being:
“The Self, in a certain sense, is the permanent, eternal state or part of ourselves, and the ‘I’ is its reflection in the area or field of the personality.” — The Multiplicities Within the Human Being
In Transpersonal Development he distinguishes the permanence of ordinary self-awareness from its source:
“Thus the essential characteristic of self-awareness is continuity and permanence, but the self-awareness of the conscious ‘I’ is only a poor reflection of the enduring, immortal essence of the spiritual ‘I’, the Self.” — Transpersonal Development, p. 26
Its fullest description comes from the experience of the Self itself:
“A clear and full experience of the self gives, at first, such a strong sense of self-identity that it is felt as something sure, permanent, unchangeable, and indestructible. It is realized as such an essential reality that all other experiences and so-called realities appear, when compared to it, as changing, impermanent and of less value and significance.” — The Mystery of the Self
He sets this against psychic phenomena, which change, combine and pass away:
“Pure Spirit, on the other hand, is immutable, eternal, simple, universal; it is pure subjectivity and unity; it is sat-chit-ananda; that is, being, consciousness, bliss and love.” — Inner Life II – The Inner World
The pair permanent / changing is also the pair eternal / transitory. Using the language of Samkhya philosophy, The Study of Self calls self-observation a discrimination “between the ‘eternal observer’ and the field of manifestation … the difference between the eternal and the transitory, between the fixed and the mutable.”
A meditation outline from 1936 states it as a principle of practice:
“…emotions and thoughts are constantly in transformation, in perennial fluctuation: only the I remains immutable, as it is. Only the I, the Soul, gives us the sense of stability, rest, and true security; a permanent reality.” — Development of the “Esoteric Sense” and Intuition, c. 2 May 1936, AAP-PRF Archive (English translation from the Italian)
4. Indestructible and immortal: the language of the Gita and the Upanishads
When Assagioli speaks of the indestructibility of the Self, he often borrows from Indian scripture. He names his witnesses in About Immortality: “The Upanishads and Bhagavad-Gita, the Old and the New Testament, Plato, Plotinus, mystics of all religions…” The realization of immortality, he says there, “can only be achieved through, or within, the spiritual psyche.” He closes the article with a translation from the Gita:
“The Spirit never dies; the Spirit will never cease to exist. There was never a time when it was not. Beginnings and endings are dreams. Unborn, immortal, immutable, the Spirit always remains. Death does not touch it in any way, even though its ‘home’ may seem without life.” — About Immortality (translation from the Bhagavad Gita)
The same passage, in Edwin Arnold’s verse translation, is set as an affirmation in the three-year course:
“Never the spirit was born; / The spirit shall cease to be never. / Never was time it was not; / End and beginning are dreams! / Birthless and deathless and changeless / Remaineth the spirit forever…” — Meditation Group for the New Age, Third Year, Set IV, p. 4, introduced as “a triumphant affirmation of the truth of our immortality”
In The Art of Synthesis – II he quotes Krishna’s reasons to Arjuna: “Death does not touch the immortal soul” and “The spirit that dwells in everyone’s body is indestructible … therefore you shouldn’t be sorry for any creature.” The course’s invocation for the transmutation of fear takes up the old Upanishadic prayer: “May I be led from darkness to Light, from the unreal to the Real, from death to Immortality” (Third Year, Set V, p. 20).
The word indestructible also appears in his own voice, outside quotation. In Transpersonal Development, of our true higher nature:
“Our true higher nature may be sedated or paralyzed for a short while, but it cannot be destroyed; it withers in its prison, being in its very nature and essence indestructible.” — Transpersonal Development, p. 258
In the same book, in the experience of illumination, “the soul now sees the universe as a living Whole and recognizes itself as an indestructible particle of it – tiny but necessary” (p. 140). And in Peace: “We remember, and realize, that we are spiritual beings and that our spiritual essence is indestructible.”
An unpublished Italian meditation method puts the whole sequence into an affirmation in the first person:
«IO SONO in Realtà e in essenza soprattutto UN ESSERE SPIRITUALE. In quanto essere spirituale nulla può toccarmi; io sono immortale, io sono eterno. Potrò passare attraverso varie esperienze, ma io sono indistruttibile.»
“I AM in Reality and in essence above all A SPIRITUAL BEING. As a spiritual being nothing can touch me; I am immortal, I am eternal. I may pass through various experiences, but I am indestructible.” — 9° Metodo, Archivio Assagioli (provisional English translation)
A shorter English form survives in the Valmy course of 1958: “Then you affirm your identification with the Self, ‘I am a permanent, self-existing being, a living reality.’”
5. The eternal now: not endless duration
Assagioli is careful about what eternal means. It is not time going on forever:
“This expansion in time, this inclusion of ever-widening cycles, serves as a preparation for the passage—one might say the leap—from time to the eternal, understood not as unlimited duration, but as an extra-temporal transcendental dimension, in which our inner center, the Self, exists and persists above the flow of the temporal current.” — Symbols of Transpersonal Experience
“The transpersonal Self is ‘outside’ time and above it. It exists and lives in the dimension of the Eternal.” — The Conflict Between Generations
Nor is it an eternity cut off from life. The Self lives in the eternal now:
“…the Self has a sense of what is eternal – or, to be more accurate, it lives in eternity. But it is the eternal ‘now’ that it inhabits, not merely a transcendent eternity, cut off from the evolutionary process of development. ‘Eternal now’ is a paradoxical expression only be appreciated intuitively, but it provides us with a key to a fundamental truth, and that is connected to the relation between the transcendent and the immanent, being and becoming.” — Transpersonal Development, p. 77
The practical consequence, in his own words to a visitor: “The great thing, difficult but possible, is to live at the same time in the eternal and in the temporal” (Conversation with Roberto Assagioli).
6. How permanence is experienced, and what it does
Permanence is not, for Assagioli, a doctrine to be believed. It is reached by disidentification, and the experience brings its own conviction. Whoever has consciously realized the spiritual Self as distinct from body, emotions and mind, he writes, has
“…the intimate – non-communicable proof, but for him irrefutable – of immortality, of the essential difference between what is spiritual, permanent, simple and intangible, and what is instead the phenomenal flow of the world of becoming.” — Psychosynthesis and Parapsychology, p. 77
Its most practical fruit is the overcoming of fear, above all the fear of death:
“Only by disidentification from the body, only by a felt conviction of the continuity of life, only by identifying with one’s spiritual Self, and experiencing the sense of immortality, of indestructibility that comes with it — only then can that biological fear be mastered and eliminated.” — Psychic Crises and Conflicts
“Realizing our true spiritual being and its indestructibility, immortality, and latent powers; identification with eternal individuality. Thus, the sense of weakness and inferiority characteristic of the personality disappear, fear and pain disappear, as does the fear of death.” — Two Lectures on the Topic of Fear
Permanence also gives the self its function. “Archimedes said: ‘Give me a point of support and I will raise the world’. Now, in order to lift the world that exists within us, the point of support is the Self, the fixed and dynamic center of our being” (The Self – Enlargement and Elevation). What does not change can hold and direct what does. Even the joy of the Soul carries this quality: it has “a note of permanency, of quiet, which is very different from the so-called joys of the personality” (Meditation Group for the New Age, Second Year, Set V, p. 9).
7. Qualifications
Assagioli did not leave permanence as a simple doctrine, and four qualifications belong with it.
Permanence is only half the picture. The self is “the fixed and dynamic center.” In the self-identification exercise the static self-awareness is joined at once by “a dynamic power… capable of observing, mastering, directing.” Right after describing the permanent element, The Interplay of Psychic Forces adds that images of it are “worthwhile in highlighting only the static element of the ‘I’ (self) which is certainly a very important element; but they fail, however, to manifest its dynamic and vital element. For the ‘I’ is itself also a living and active entity.” Permanence describes the centre, not the whole life of the person, which is meant to grow.
The experience fluctuates. The Mystery of the Self passage says the experience is felt as permanent “at first”. In the personal self the realization comes and goes; it is “submerged in the ceaseless flow of psychological contents” and “seems to disappear altogether” in sleep. What is permanent is the centre, not our awareness of it.
Not everything called “Soul” is permanent. At Capolona in 1973 Assagioli distinguished the Soul as causal body, “the egoic lotus, which is composed of several streams of qualified mental energy”, from what lies at its centre: “the jewel, the monadic spark, the divine immortal center.” Immortality belongs to the spark, not to the causal vehicle. Statements that the Soul “fades out of the picture” refer to the vehicle.
Survival is not the same as immortality. In On Survival After Death Assagioli treats survival as a question that research can approach, and expressly sets aside “the relations between psyche and spirit; i.e. immortality.” In a 1955 conversation he draws the line clearly:
“…the immortal is only the best [part], it is the pure consciousness of one’s spiritual being. There is a permanent ‘I’ or Self unrelated to the mood swings of the ordinary ‘I’ or self. The transition from survival to immortality takes place when the living consciousness of immortality is realized, already in the bodily life.” — Notes From a Conversation with Dr. Assagioli
Permanence of the Self is a claim about immortality in this second sense, and it is realized “already in the bodily life”, not deferred to after death.
Why permanence matters in Psychosynthesis
Permanence is what makes disidentification possible and safe. If the self were one more content of consciousness, letting go of contents would leave nothing behind. Because the “I” is “the permanent factor in the ever varying flow”, a person can step back from feelings, roles and thoughts and discover a point of stability rather than a void. That stability is the ground for the will, for the overcoming of fear, and for the gradual realization of the transpersonal Self, which Assagioli describes as indestructible and as living in the eternal now. In this sense permanence links the two ends of Psychosynthesis: the first psychological discovery, “I am I”, and the spiritual realization of an immortal centre.
Related entries
Sources
Books
- Assagioli, Roberto. Psychosynthesis: A Manual of Principles and Techniques. New York: Hobbs, Dorman & Company, 1965.
- Assagioli, Roberto. The Act of Will. New York: Viking Press, 1973.
- Assagioli, Roberto. Transpersonal Development: The Dimension Beyond Psychosynthesis. London: Crucible, 1991.
- Assagioli, Roberto. Psychosynthesis and Parapsychology. Edited by Kenneth Sørensen. 2nd ed. Kentaur Publishing, 2023.
- Meditation Group for the New Age, Second and Third Year course sets, written by Roberto Assagioli with Michal Eastcott and Nancy Magor. Page references are to the Meditation Mount reprints, Ojai, California.
Articles, talks and interviews on kennethsorensen.dk
- About Immortality
- The Art of Synthesis – II
- Conflict, Crises, and Synthesis – Introduction (Psychic Crises and Conflicts)
- The Conflict Between Generations & Psychosynthesis
- Conversation with Roberto Assagioli
- Inner Life II – The Inner World
- The Interplay of Psychic Forces
- The Multiplicities Within the Human Being
- The Mystery of the “I”
- The Mystery of the Self
- Notes From a Conversation with Dr. Assagioli
- On Survival After Death
- Peace
- Psychology and Parapsychology
- The Self – Enlargement and Elevation of Consciousness
- The Self and Self
- The Study of Self
- Symbols of Transpersonal Experience
- Talks on the Self, personal self and transpersonal Self (1973)
- The Psychology of Idea-Forces and Psychagogy
- Two Lectures on the Topic of Fear
Unpublished sources
- “Development of the ‘Esoteric Sense’ and Intuition”, meditation outline, c. 2 May 1936, AAP-PRF Archive (English translation from the Italian).
- Psychosynthesis Research Foundation, Transcript of Conference, Valmy, Greenville, Delaware, 1958.
- Didactic session with Roberto Assagioli, Capolona, 9 July 1973, Fourth Session (transcript).
- 9° Metodo, Archivio Assagioli, Florence.