Contentless Awareness: Assagioli on the Self as Pure Awareness Free of All Content
Compiled by Kenneth Sørensen, MA, with help from Claude AI.
What is contentless awareness?
Contentless describes the experience of the self as pure awareness, free of every content of consciousness. Sensations, feelings, desires, thoughts, images and roles are contents. They come and go in the field of consciousness. The self is not one of them. It is the centre that is aware of them. When a person disidentifies from all contents, what remains is not nothing. It is the self itself, experienced as pure self-awareness.
For Roberto Assagioli this is one of the essential qualities of the self, and it holds at both levels. The personal self, the conscious “I”, is “devoid of any content”. The Higher or Transpersonal Self is “a pure centre of spiritual consciousness, devoid of any content”. The self is therefore not a process, a function or a state of mind. Processes belong to the contents of consciousness, and the self is what is aware of them.
Assagioli does not use the adjective “contentless” himself. His phrases are “devoid of any content”, “without any content”, “independent of any content”, “free from any particular content”, “without any definite content”, “without any ‘object’” and “without attributes”. The glossary term gathers these expressions under one word.
1. The self is not its contents
The starting point is a distinction that introspection can check: the contents of consciousness change, while the one who is aware of them does not.
“The ‘self’, that is to say, the point of pure self-awareness, is often confused with the conscious personality just described, but in reality it is quite different from it. This can be ascertained by the use of careful introspection. The changing contents of our consciousness (the sensations, thoughts, feelings, etc.) are one thing, while the ‘I’, the self, the center of our consciousness is another. From a certain point of view this difference can be compared to that existing between the white lighted area on a screen and the various pictures which are projected upon it.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 18
“The self in the strict sense is the point of self-awareness – pure, neutral, without any content. It is what distinguishes us from the animal, the I-reference; and the fundamental difference is that the self always remains the same – self-identity, while the contents of the consciousness change all the time… with a stage, many characters come in and out, but the stage remains the same; but more than the stage is the consciousness of the self, the I.” — Psychosynthesis Research Foundation conference, Valmy, May 1958, transcript p. 31
“The normal mistake we all make is to identify ourselves with some content of consciousness rather than with consciousness itself. Some people get their identity from their feelings, others from their thoughts, others from their social roles. But this identification with a part of the personality destroys the freedom which comes from the experience of the pure ‘I’.” — The Golden Mean of Roberto Assagioli (interview with Sam Keen, 1974)
“The personal self, however, is represented as a point, independent of any particular contents, data or impulses. Each of us has this central point of personal awareness, which we can experience simply by acknowledging that we are aware of various contents of consciousness, but we are not those contents.” — The Rebirth of the Soul (interview with Stuart Miller, 1973)
In the meditation course he prepared for the Meditation Group for the New Age, Assagioli makes the same distinction the basis of reflective meditation on oneself: “It requires clear discrimination between pure self-consciousness and the psychological ‘contents’ of our personality” (Meditation Group for the New Age, First Year, Set II, p. 7).
2. The personal self: pure self-awareness, devoid of any content
“The second meaning which can be given to ‘self-identification’ is the inner experience of pure self-awareness, independent of any content or function of the ego in the sense of personality. Curiously, it is a subject which has been neglected, and the explanation is that the experience of pure self-identity—or in other words, of the self, the I-consciousness, devoid of any content—does not arise spontaneously but is the result of a definite inner experimentation.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 112
“In my opinion, the direct experience of the self, of pure self-awareness—independent of any ‘content’ of the field of consciousness and of any situation in which the individual may find himself—is a true, ‘phenomenological’ experience, an inner reality which can be empirically verified and deliberately produced through appropriate techniques.” — Psychosynthesis, pp. 4–5
“There is one thing that is hard enough to realise: the ego has, or rather is, a center of pure consciousness, of pure self-awareness, at the personal level, devoid of all empirical and historical contents… As I have said in my book, the ego or I or personal self is devoid of any content; it is pure self-awareness, persisting throughout the stream of experiences and changes. The exercise of dis-identification helps in the realisation of this.” — Dialogue with Roberto Assagioli (with Martha Crampton)
“If we eliminate the content, we remain. The self remains. Pure self awareness, not ecstatic, but it has in itself a sense of assurance, of inner certainty, security, permanence, which is already much. But it is a quiet subtle thing.” — Talks on the Self (1973)
“It is according to the principle that the ego must recognise itself as a pure center of self-awareness, free from any particular content.” — Psychosynthesis Training with Roberto Assagioli
“…that stable and permanent element can be regarded as the principle of self-consciousness, of that reflexive self-awareness that gives us a sense of being, of being absolutely, without attributes.” — The Interplay of Psychic Forces
In the exercise of disidentification Assagioli adds that man “can arrive at pure consciousness of the ‘I,’ free from all identification” (Exercise of Disidentification and Self-Identification). He also recommends making this a daily practice: a “double-awakening” each morning, first from sleep and then “the awakening of clear self-consciousness, that is, self-awareness; of one’s self, free and independent of any ‘content’ or psychic element: physical sensations, emotions, or mental activities” (An Overview of Psychological Life).
3. The observer: the contentless self at work
The contentless self is not experienced as a blank. It is experienced as the observer: the one who sees the contents without being any of them. For Assagioli the observer is the first, practical form of the contentless experience, and the place where it can be tested. (See also the glossary entry The observer.)
“It means, as its terminology clearly indicates, directing the mind’s eye, or the observing function, upon the world of psychological facts, of psychological events, of which we can be aware. Through introspection we acquire a more focussed and clear awareness of what William James called the mind-stream, ceaselessly flowing within ourselves. It could also be called the attitude of the observer, the inner observer.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 114
The observation itself shows that the observer is not what it observes: “the very fact that the self can observe, take notice and exercise its powers of observation on the mental activity proves the difference between the self and the mind” (p. 115). And as the contents are seen to change, the observer is found to remain: “This objective observation produces naturally, spontaneously and inevitably a sense of dis-identification from any and all of those psychological contents and activities. By contrast the stability, the permanency of the observer is realized” (p. 116).
“Keen: This technique is similar to the Buddhist vipassana meditation in which one merely observes passing thoughts, sensations and images. Assagioli: Yes, and it leads to the affirmation that the observer is different from what he observes.” — The Golden Mean of Roberto Assagioli (interview with Sam Keen, 1974)
“What then is the ‘I?’ What am I? First and foremost, and essentially, a center of pure awareness; a kind of inner eye, which observes, perceives and knows that it sees; and therefore perceives self-awareness.” — Psychology and Parapsychology
“There is a higher and more important form of concentration than those types so far dealt with. It is that of the Observer or inner Spectator who, perfectly concentrated, observes the flowing panorama of the psychological life—called by William James the ‘mind stream’—and in a detached way perceives it, assesses it and, when needed, intervenes to change it… we have to draw it back continually to the center of concentration, to the self, the part in us which is persistent and unchanging throughout all the variations of the psychological flow.” — Meditation Group for the New Age, First Year, Set I, p. 22
The same course says that disidentification “implies the assumption and maintenance of the inner attitude of the Observer; in other words, the achievements of true self-awareness, i.e., the awareness of That within us which, permanent and immutable, lies behind, or rather above, the endless variety of transient psychological states” (Third Year, Set VI, “The Technique of Indifference”).
Assagioli connects this with the oldest Indian psychology. Self-observation leads to “discrimination between the self and the not-self (the I and the not-I)… between the ‘eternal observer’ and the field of manifestation — to use the terms of Samkhya philosophy. It is the difference between the eternal and the transitory, between the fixed and the mutable” (The Study of Self).
The observer is not a passive onlooker. Assagioli speaks of “the ‘consciousness of the observer,’ or, in modern theatrical terms, the director” (The Resolution of Conflicts), and the stable observer discovers “another important function of the self: that it is not merely an observer, but it can also be active in modifying the personality” (see section 6).
4. The Higher Self: a centre without content
The same quality belongs to the Higher or Transpersonal Self. Assagioli uses it to separate the Self from the superconscious, which is full of contents.
“There are many superconscious elements and activities which are definite psychological processes or elements, but they are not the Self. The Self is a pure centre of spiritual consciousness, devoid of any content, whereas the superconscious is but a higher level of our psychological being.” — The Multiplicities Within the Human Being
“For the Transpersonal Self is reality; it is of the same nature as the Universal Reality. Therefore its energy is charged with power and bliss, without any definite content. For this reason the ultimate reality to which it belongs has been described in terms of purity. This is the absence of specific quality, which is arrived at through the harmonious synthesis of all qualities (just as white light, the absence of colour, is the combination in right proportions of all colours). It is the void in a positive sense, the ‘Suchness of the Void’, a void which contains all life, to which everything belongs, and in which all is combined. This is the true contact with the Self. All the rest is contact with the superconscious.” — The Superconscious and the Self
“The Void – the transcendence of bounded space and of all that is contained in space – has been described as terrifying or blissful in different circumstances. This paradoxical nature of the Self is perhaps best stated by the Buddhist formula: ‘Neither being, nor not-being, nor both being and not-being, nor neither being nor not-being’!” — The Superconscious and the Self, in the section “The Self as the Void”
“Self-realization, in this specific well-defined sense, means the momentary or more or less temporary identification or blending of the I-consciousness with the spiritual Self… In these cases there is a forgetfulness of all contents of consciousness, of all which forms the personality both on normal levels and those of the synthesized personality which include superconscious or spiritual levels of life and experience; there is only the pure intense experience of the Self.” — Psychosynthesis, p. 202
“But if we succeed for a few moments in stopping the ‘mental stream’ and keeping the field of consciousness free from the states of mind that usually occupy it, we can come to have a certain consciousness of the deep Self.” — The Mystery of the “I”
At Valmy in 1958 Robert Gerard asked whether one might visualize the higher Self as a point of light. Assagioli allowed symbols as aids, but added: “The symbol of light, of the jewel, of the wise man, can help but should be recognized as a means, as a symbol, and not as the reality. The true experience is formless” (transcript p. 58).
He also recorded the experience himself, in prison in 1940: “an attempt to realise the consciousness of the pure Self without any ‘object.’ Gradually a sense of light, of stability, of permanency as a diamond” (Freedom in Jail, p. 37).
5. Not a process
Because it has no content, the self is not a process. Processes, even the highest, belong to the world of becoming.
“The basic difference is that all of these are processes, living processes. They belong to the world of becoming and even at the transpersonal there is this wonderful process of becoming, of growth, of all the phases of super-consciousness. But the Self in contradistinction is stable, firm, permanent – to use the philosophical word ‘ontological’. It is Pure Being.” — Talks on the Self
“…while in the region of the superconscious many psychological activities take place and psychological functions are active, the Self is instead an immobile point of awareness, which is fixed, immutable, in a certain sense transcendent, although emanating powerful energies.” — Psychosynthesis – Its Essential Components
“The Self is without dimensions; it is both a geometric point that occupies no space; it is both zero and infinity, the ‘Laya Point’, Aristotle’s ‘Unmoved Mover’. And it radiates beams of energy, emanates an energy field.” — The Superconscious and the Self
6. How the experience is reached
The contentless self is not reached by thinking about it but by a practice of withdrawal from contents. Assagioli traced his exercise to pratyahara, the withdrawal of attention in Raja Yoga:
“So pratyahara, detachment, disidentification, not only from the physical senses, but from all contents and functions, all activities of the personality. With these successive dis-identifications through the ascent of consciousness to higher and higher levels or — to use another metaphor, with these ‘retreats,’ from the periphery or surface to the inner center of ourselves, we arrive at the consciousness of the ‘I,’ of self, devoid of any particular content or determination; at pure self-consciousness.” — Note on Raja Yoga, Archivio Assagioli, Doc. 16656, quoted in Why You Are Not Your Body
Inner silence is the means, and Assagioli calls the result a void:
“In order to strengthen and make stable the pure self-awareness of the observer, it is necessary to have periods of inner silence, gradually longer, to make what is called the void in the field of consciousness. Then one discovers another important function of the self: that it is not merely an observer, but it can also be active in modifying the personality.” — Height Psychology — Discovering the self and the Self (interview)
He used “silence” in this strict sense: “Silence is not only refraining from speech, but also refraining from inner mental activity” (Valmy, 1958). And: “in the absence of ordinary emotions and feelings, in that emptiness, in that inner silence, spiritual consciousness sometimes awakens… one has a sense, a direct perception of the Spiritual ‘I’” (Disidentification from the Emotions and the Body).
In the meditation course the first step of creative meditation is “eliminating as much as possible from the field of consciousness all preconceived, existing contents (thoughts, emotions, desires, etc.)” (Meditation Group for the New Age, Second Year, Set I, p. 4). For spiritual realization, “the use of the will is required for controlling the other psychological functions and keeping them temporarily quiescent while the center of consciousness reaches up to and is one-pointedly fixed in the spiritual or trans-personal Self” (Third Year, Set VI).
Removing contents is also the way from the personal to the Higher Self: “the conscious ‘I’ is a ‘reflection’ of the Self and is thus essentially of the same nature, however much it is weakened and ‘coloured’ by the contents of the middle level of the personality. When one manages to eliminate those contents by means of certain exercises (particularly that of disidentification), the conscious ‘I’ tends to return upwards to its origin” (Transpersonal Development, p. 40). In meditation without a theme, “the contemplation is a state of perfect repose, an inner silence, taking the form of pure consciousness of being” (p. 36).
In a dialogue on the separativity of the “I”, he insists that this point of awareness is kept, not given up:
“D.: So, when people talk about ‘transcending the ego’, they must actually transcend the separativity of the ‘I’. R.A.: Yes, without losing the center point. The point of pure self-awareness. This is valuable and must be kept. It must only be freed from what it is attached to, and then it naturally rises, and it is precious even before rising. It is awareness. This is a point that needs to be clarified very well, because there is such confusion about it.” — The Separativity of the “I”, translated by Jan Kuniholm
7. Qualifications
- Contentless is not empty. Assagioli rejects the reading of the void as nothingness: “People take the expression too literally, consider the void as something absolute and negative, and almost non-being. But it is not that at all… It is the void of all personal and even transpersonal […], but that leaves the fullness of being, the ‘such-ness’… the void is fullness; only fullness of something quite different from the ordinary: a fullness of Being; void of becoming and fullness of being” (didactic session, Capolona, 14 July 1973). The same “void in a positive sense” appears in The Superconscious and the Self, and in the meditation course ultimate Reality is described “as Void, as No-thing (which does not mean ‘nothing’ in the ordinary sense)” (Meditation Group for the New Age, Third Year, Set I, p. 3).
- Contentless is not passive. The centre of awareness is also a centre of will: “this center not only has a static self-awareness but also a dynamic power; it is capable of observing, mastering, directing and using all the psychological processes and the physical body. I am a center of awareness and of power” (Psychosynthesis, p. 119). In receptive meditation the will keeps the consciousness “in a state of positive poise, of calm watchfulness, keeping the mind still and at the same time avoiding a negative dreamy condition” (Meditation Group for the New Age, Second Year, Set IV, p. 3).
- It is a centre, not a place to live. “Even at the personality level we don’t, nor should we, live in the pure self-consciousness of the ‘I’. The ‘I’ creates its personality” (The Superconscious and the Self). The experience of the contentless self is the basis for personal psychosynthesis, not a withdrawal from life.
- It can at first feel like isolation. In the same note on Raja Yoga he warns that the exercise gives some a joyful sense of freedom, but gives others “a painful sense of isolation, loneliness — what has been called ‘existential angst’… but it is the effect of an illusion. The I, the self, is not isolated; it is in communion with others and participates in universal Life” (note on Raja Yoga, Archivio Assagioli; see also Why You Are Not Your Body).
- Words only point to it. Like everything essential, it “can hardly be expressed in words, and can only be ‘indicated’ indirectly and imperfectly” (The Interplay of Psychic Forces). Assagioli’s analogies, the white screen, the empty stage, white light, are pointers, not descriptions.
Why contentless awareness matters in Psychosynthesis
The contentless self is what makes disidentification possible: one can step back from every content only because the one who steps back is not a content. It also marks the line Assagioli drew again and again between the Self and the superconscious. The superconscious is rich in contents, intuitions, inspirations and illuminations. The Self has none. It is the awareness in which they appear.
Related entries: The observer · Pure awareness · Self-identification · Disidentification · The Self · Superconscious · Essentialism
Sources
Books by Roberto Assagioli
- Assagioli, Roberto. Psychosynthesis: A Manual of Principles and Techniques. New York: Hobbs, Dorman, 1965. Page references are to the Viking Compass edition, New York: Viking Press, 1971.
- Assagioli, Roberto. Transpersonal Development: The Dimension Beyond Psychosynthesis. Forres: Smiling Wisdom, 2007.
- Assagioli, Roberto. Freedom in Jail. Introduced, edited and annotated by Catherine Ann Lombard. Florence: Istituto di Psicosintesi, 2016.
- Meditation Group for the New Age, First, Second and Third Year (eighteen course sets, 1960s), written by Roberto Assagioli with Michal Eastcott and Nancy Magor. Page references are to the Meditation Mount reprints, Ojai, California.
Articles, talks and interviews on kennethsorensen.dk
- An Overview of Psychological Life
- Dialogue with Roberto Assagioli
- Disidentification from the Emotions and the Body
- Exercise of Disidentification and Self-Identification
- The Golden Mean of Roberto Assagioli (interview with Sam Keen, 1974)
- Height Psychology — Discovering the self and the Self
- The Interplay of Psychic Forces
- The Multiplicities Within the Human Being
- The Mystery of the “I”
- Psychology and Parapsychology
- Psychosynthesis Training with Roberto Assagioli
- Psychosynthesis – Its Essential Components
- The Rebirth of the Soul (interview with Stuart Miller, 1973)
- The Resolution of Conflicts & Spiritual Conflicts and Crises
- The Study of Self
- The Superconscious and the Self
- Talks on the Self, personal self and transpersonal Self (1973)
- Why You Are Not Your Body (quoting the Raja Yoga note, Archivio Assagioli, Doc. 16656)
Unpublished sources
- Psychosynthesis Research Foundation, Transcript of Conference, Valmy, Greenville, Delaware, 23–25 May 1958.
- Didactic Session no. 9 with Roberto Assagioli, Capolona, 14 July 1973 (transcript).
- “The Separativity of the ‘I’” (Separatività dell’Io), Archivio Assagioli, translated by Jan Kuniholm: kennethsorensen.dk